An assignment for class that I feel merits a share, given the themes of conversations had within the last few months. May you embrace the fullness of your otherness and of those around you.
N.A.
þ Other
Lopez Lyman
in her article, We Got Issues:
Cultivating a Women of Color Consciousness (2014), shares her experiences
of having been both singled out and isolated in the school environment she grew
up in; however, she forged a community after finding herself again alone within
her collegiate journey. Alsultany in her article, Los Intersticios: Recasting Moving Scales, shares many accounts of
how she has been [mis]identified within social contexts and placates to this
misidentification, yet yearns to be seen for the fullness of who she
is—unfragmented. As Alsultany, Lopez Lyman, and I have taken time to explore our
identities, we share three common experiences: the pain of feeling displaced
within scholarly contexts, wrestling with a place of belonging, and influencing
change in how we as people see one another.
As a result of the
difficulties Lopez Lyman faced with being singled out in school, she sought to create
a place of belonging within her college that she found so readily within the
pages of books. To start with, Lopez Lyman felt singled out and isolated for
being different within her journey of education. She recalls times in school
when, “all eyes landed on me anytime race was discussed” (Lopez Lyman, 2014, p.
56). Having been singled out, Lopez Lyman found herself alone and desiring a
sense of companionship within this space. Later in her schooling, she
discovered a sense of belonging through the works of authors who have lived
through similar difficulties. Lopez Lyman (2014) describes her source of
encouragement: “Having combatted a deep loneliness for years, I found
companionship through the work of Cherríe Moraga, Gloria Anazaldúa, Audra Lorde
and others who gave voice to isolation and hopefulness for survival” (p. 56).
Once we are able to find a source of strength, so much more can be achieved.
Moreover, Lopez Lyman was able to play a key role in bringing about change on
her University’s campus. She recounts the need she encountered on campus: “What
became essential to the collective, however, was our understanding of multiple
identities and our commitment to centralize our lived experiences, both of
which became catalysts for creating change on and off campus” (Lopez Lyman,
2014, p. 57). We must be able to recognize within ourselves and within one
another the complex beings that we are. When reconciling our identities with
the struggle we’ve encountered from our past, we can create a new place in which
to belong.
As Alsultany has
explored her identity, she navigated through the pain of displacement, wrestled
with a space in which to belong, and now seeks to reshape the present molds
from which our society views one another. First, Alsultany struggled with the
categories that people projected onto and omitted from her. This can be seen
when she shares, “Those who otherize me fail to see a shared humanity, and
those who identify with me fail to see difference; my Arab or Muslim identity
negates my Cuban heritage” (Alsultany, 2014, p. 62). Unable to meet people’s
clear-cut racial (or other generalization) paradigms, we can find ourselves
caught in the places in-between, in los intersticios. Additionally, Alsultany
wrestles with a sense of belonging from within los intersticios. She describes
this feeling of not belonging: “We carry this pain with us as we live in los
intersticios. To ‘belong’ we must fragment and exclude particular parts of our
identity. Dislocation results from the narrow ways in which the body is read,
the rigid frameworks imposed on the body in public space” (Alsultany, 2014,
p.64). After focusing so much energy on how she is framed within certain
contexts, Alsultany advocates for more. Consequently, Alsultany instigates change
through dialogue. Her heart for the matter is conveyed when she shares, “I seek
to decolonize these essentialized frameworks, so that I can move through public
space without strategizing a performance, selecting a mask for each scenario. I
want to expand los intersticios, creating a space. for us all in our
multiplicities to exist as unified subjects” (Alsultany, 2014, p. 65). She invites
us to enter into spaces that may be uncomfortable in order to expand los
intersticios that we encounter within our own lives. Furthermore, Alsultany not
only encourages us to expand these intersticios but to also shed light on where
people are feeling displaced in their own sense of belonging in order to instigate
change within our own communities.
Similar (and
different) to the struggles Lopez Lyman and Alsultany faced, I too have faced
the pain of feeling displaced, journeying to a place of belonging, and working
towards creating a safe place for others to belong as well. The feeling of
displacement was evident in each of my Minnesotan and Costa Rican schools. My heart was shattered when I found grotesque
writings about me in the boy’s locker room in Costa Rica. This mirrored the
pain I had endured when being ostracized by jealous schoolgirls in Minnesota,
which had at that time caused me to fragment and reject of the fullness of all
that I am. Because of this, I was caught in los intersticios, I wrestled with
who I was and where I was from. Seeking comfort I encountered a Biblical verse:
“Consequently,
you are no longer foreigners and strangers, but fellow citizens with
God’s people and also members of his household” (Ephesians 2:19, New
International Version). Finding these words and those that preceded it left my
heart at ease as I pictured my passport cover’s gold crest as an ornate
heavenly image and within its pages the two citizenships that I hold within an
earthly realm. From this place, I recognized that everybody belongs- everyone
is beloved. When walking with a
friend, he questioned my desire to say hello to everyone, and I responded that
it isn’t a desire but a need. I need to
acknowledge those that I encounter because
I don’t know who they are or what they are facing, and my acknowledgement of
the gift of their passing presence within my life is sacred ground. Throughout
each day, I desire to and implore others to join me to take a step back, to
notice those around us, to extend a place of belonging and to be the influence
that combats that which seeks to destroy our sense of identity.
References
Asultany, E. (2014). Los intersticios: Recasting moving scales. In C.K. Farr, M.M.
Phillips, & N.A. Heitzeg (Eds.), The Catherine core reader (pp.61-65).
Acton, MA: XanEdu.
Lopez Lyman, J. (2014). We got issues: Cultivating a women of color consciousness. In C.K.
Farr, M.M. Phillips, & N.A. Heitzeg
(Eds.), The Catherine core reader
(pp. 55-59). Acton, MA: XanEdu.
